PDA

View Full Version : random morning idea


pinkshirtphotos
06-24-2008, 11:27 AM
The price is food is going up, one of the reasons is gas prices. Farmers can apply for something that makes them "farm assessed" which means they pay less taxes. Lowered property taxes, and no tax on items for their livestock/ fields. (this gets messy with horse farmers because of the tac sometimes). Well why should they pay the state and federal tax on gas? The government should offer farmers the same tax break on gas as they offer on feed, after all no farmers no food. The farmers should be able to fill up at a gas station, save the receipt and mail them all in to the government at the end of the year and get their federal and state taxes back. Some farmers have their own fuel tanks with ag grade fuel but not many do.

X3pilot
06-24-2008, 11:30 AM
Your post reads more like Random thoughts in no particular sequence.

Exactly what are you trying to say?

A. Farmers shouldn't have to pay taxes?

B. "Farm assessed" is another name for entitlement?

C. Flood the government with receipts?

D. The majority of farmers don't have their own fuel tanks?

:wtf:

binary visions
06-24-2008, 11:31 AM
Also:

You can pay less tax, or you can pay fewer taxes.

Just filling in for sunny during her patrol suspension.

TN
06-24-2008, 11:34 AM
I think they get diesel cheaper. I could be wrong, but I remember something being said about that in a conversation a while back. Or maybe I was paying attention.

pinkshirtphotos
06-24-2008, 11:34 AM
farmers should pay no tax on gas, allowing them to grow more crops at a lower price. They can then transfer the savings to the consumer.

stevew
06-24-2008, 11:36 AM
Keep this s**t to yourself next time pinky.

CRoss
06-24-2008, 11:37 AM
If they do not have a tank of off road diesel(no taxes) to use in their equipment it is their own fault for not saving money.

And who is to say once they start saving money on fuel they will lower their prices?

Spero
06-24-2008, 11:38 AM
I wish I could find it but a year or so ago I came across a map of New York City with residences that had filed for ag exemptions. It was amazing to me how many people in the heart of the city were farmers.

Westy
06-24-2008, 11:40 AM
The price of food has little to do with the cost to produce it. For years farmers lost money when prices were low. It is all about supply and demand. Right now the demand is very high partly because gas is expensive and they are putting farm resources into ethanol. Subsiding fuel costs for farmers would just mean more profits for farmers with little incentive for them to save fuel.

narlus
06-24-2008, 11:45 AM
businesses should pay no tax on energy, allowing them to product more at a lower price. They can then transfer the savings to the consumer.

:banana:

Konabumm
06-24-2008, 11:49 AM
The price is food is going up, one of the reasons is gas prices. Farmers can apply for something that makes them "farm assessed" which means they pay less taxes. Lowered property taxes, and no tax on items for their livestock/ fields. (this gets messy with horse farmers because of the tac sometimes). Well why should they pay the state and federal tax on gas? The government should offer farmers the same tax break on gas as they offer on feed, after all no farmers no food. The farmers should be able to fill up at a gas station, save the receipt and mail them all in to the government at the end of the year and get their federal and state taxes back. Some farmers have their own fuel tanks with ag grade fuel but not many do.

Run for government -

CRoss
06-24-2008, 12:00 PM
Run for government -


He is way to smart to be in the government.

jonKranked
06-24-2008, 12:13 PM
you guys are really quick to jump on him, but I don't think its a half bad idea. I doubt we'd ever see it enacted. But farmers have been getting tax breaks and the like more or less since the Great Depression.

Toshi
06-24-2008, 12:19 PM
If they do not have a tank of off road diesel(no taxes) to use in their equipment it is their own fault for not saving money.

And who is to say once they start saving money on fuel they will lower their prices?

Ditto to both points. If the equipment is being used on roads (as would be assumed if fueling up at a commercial pump) then the excise tax is fully warranted.

The Joker
06-24-2008, 12:27 PM
If you want to lower prices on commodities, remove the govt subsidies. This will mean more of the farmers will produce, allowing a larger supply reducing prices. The market needs to regulate prices, not the govt.

TSchultz
06-24-2008, 02:35 PM
Just one point, farmers are not the ones who raise and lower thier prices. It's the companies that they sell the commodities to that control the price in the grocery store. Farming is one of the very few businesses that take their product to the market and told what they can get for it. Most businesses take there product to maket and charge what the market will bear.

One other thing to ponder is that while everyone is thinking that farmers are making butt loads of money with high corn prices right now, what they fail to realize is that most of the coming years crops have already sold at a more average price.

Lowlight7
06-24-2008, 02:46 PM
This would be a drop in the bucket compared to the other assistance that farmers get.

It's supply and demand.

Unseasonable drought + idled farmland + natural diasters + Fewer food independent third world markets = less supply

Fewer food independent third world markets + population increases + diet change in newly prosperous nations + middle class size increase in Asia + proliferation of biofuels = more demand

ohio
06-24-2008, 03:58 PM
Unseasonable drought + idled farmland + natural diasters + Fewer food independent third world markets = less supply

Fewer food independent third world markets + population increases + diet change in newly prosperous nations + middle class size increase in Asia + proliferation of biofuels = more demand

Yeah, well all yer fancy math ain't putting food on my family.

Samirol
06-24-2008, 03:58 PM
Part of the problem as well is speculation, with the dollar plummeting, many investors are putting their money into commodities like wheat, corn, soybeans, etc., and it causes prices to go up.

This affects all corners of the market, since most feed is based off of those basic commodities, causing prices to rise.

However, removing the subsidies and taking a laissez-faire attitude towards farming will have some negative effects, as it will crush the already struggling small farms in the United States. In Central and South America, they can grow the exact same crops, except for considerably less.

Ethanol from sugar cane is fantastic environmentally and efficient, but harder to grow, so don't just write it off.

It is a mixture of demand from more mouths to feed, higher demand for ethanol with oil prices, oil/gas and speculation which has put us in this situation today. Paying for gas probably won't have a huge effect on the price, but the idea is decent.

Arkayne
06-24-2008, 04:17 PM
The price is food is going up, one of the reasons is gas prices. Farmers can apply for something that makes them "farm assessed" which means they pay less taxes. Lowered property taxes, and no tax on items for their livestock/ fields. (this gets messy with horse farmers because of the tac sometimes). Well why should they pay the state and federal tax on gas? The government should offer farmers the same tax break on gas as they offer on feed, after all no farmers no food. The farmers should be able to fill up at a gas station, save the receipt and mail them all in to the government at the end of the year and get their federal and state taxes back. Some farmers have their own fuel tanks with ag grade fuel but not many do.

http://i32.photobucket.com/albums/d11/pritos/MTB/1213660188156.gif

only in the spirit of psp bashing. otherwise, this doesn't sound so bad.

SkaredShtles
06-24-2008, 04:18 PM
Just one point, farmers are not the ones who raise and lower thier prices. It's the companies that they sell the commodities to that control the price in the grocery store. Farming is one of the very few businesses that take their product to the market and told what they can get for it.
Maybe if he/she is a spectacularly unsophisticated farmer... you do realize that farmers can actually *participate* in the commodities market, right?